A comparison of open-source scanner software vs proprietary Scanner SDK

When companies want to implement scanning functionality in their app, they basically can choose between three options:

• Develop the scanning feature in-house
• Integrate an open-source scanner software or
• Integrate a proprietary SDK for scanning

Developing scanning functionality from scratch is a time-consuming task for developers and thus, very expensive. Especially when the scanning feature is supposed to be ready-to-use in the app as soon as possible, the decision most often is between deciding for an open-source scanner or a proprietary scanner SDK.

Therefore, the following article focuses on the pros and cons of a proprietary Scanner SDK and an open-source software and gives advice on when to chose which option.

What is Open Source Scanner Software?

Open-source scanner software is freely available software designed for scanning documents or images, with its source code open for modification and distribution by anyone. This type of software allows users to customize features, fix bugs, and adapt it to specific needs without licensing restrictions. Examples include SANE (Scanner Access Now Easy) and NAPS2 (Not Another PDF Scanner 2).

Advantages of Open Source Software

Open-source software is mostly free of charge and has publicly available code everyone can use and contribute to. Oftentimes many knowledgeable people work on the code to audit and improve it. There are also cases where large companies back open-source tools and libraries, which make them more trustworthy. The bigger the community around an open-source tool is, the better communication and support is to be expected as well as regular update cycles.

Disadvantages of Open Source Software

Despite mentioning that there are some open-source tools that are backed by a company, most open-source libraries are not. This means they are run by individual developers, mostly unpaid, who contribute to a project as long as they deem it necessary and relevant. This can lead to open-source projects becoming outdated. Open-source solutions come with no binding support and mostly no documentation. In case of a question or a challenge, developers are dependent on community support and must hope for answers, which can be very unreliable. This means that if errors occur, developers must solve them for themselves in the worst case. This is difficult or even impossible without the relevant experience, especially with a complex topic like automated document recognition.

What is a proprietary Scanner SDK?

A proprietary Scanner SDK (Software Development Kit) is a specialized, licensed toolset provided by a company for developers to integrate scanning capabilities into their software. Unlike open-source alternatives, its source code is closed, and usage is typically governed by licensing fees or restrictions. These SDKs often offer robust support, advanced features, and compatibility with specific scanner hardware, such as TWAIN.

Check out our proprietary Scanner SDK
Learn more about the Docutain SDK, providing document scanning, data capturing, OCR, data extraction and barcode scanning functionalities. It is available for Android, iOS and Windows. In addition to native integration, the SDK can be used for the most common cross-platform frameworks.
If you want to test the Document Scanner SDK without writing any lines of code, check out our Showcase Apps for Android & iOS or have a look at our GitHub examples.

Challenges of integrating open-source software in apps

When a developer wants to integrate scanning functionality and OCR text recognition in his mobile app, it seems to be the easiest way to use an open-software library.

The reason behind is the obvious advantages of open-source software: It is mostly free of charge and the source code is publicly available. Still, developers must keep in mind that further development of the community can also lead to the solution becoming faulty or, in the worst case, it is no longer working at all. In such a case, developers basically must work on the code themselves and invest the time to find an adequate solution. They cannot reach out to an official support contact expecting immediate help.

Security risks can arise because developers may be able to install backdoors to intercept data, which is extremely critical, especially when dealing with a scanner solution that captures sensitive documents.

Furthermore, open-source scanners are generally not permanently tested on many devices by many users. This means that, at first glance, the functionality delivers good results. However, as soon as the solution is distributed to many different users and devices, one might realize that the quality in daily practice is average to poor.

With new operating system versions, adjustments often must be made to the code so that the scanner runs without errors. The developer also must do this by himself or possibly wait a very long time until the community has adapted the library.

An open-source library may also focus on one functionality only and keep it simple. This means that when searching for a scanner library, one can expect the scanning function, but not necessarily complementary features like editing or text recognition.

Another aspect to consider when using open-source software is the type of license (e.g., MIT, GPL, Apache) and its restrictions on usage, distribution, and modification.

Advantages of proprietary SDKs like Docutain Document Scanner SDK

The above-mentioned disadvantages of open-source software do not apply to proprietary software. We take the example of a developer, who wants to integrate scanning functionality and OCR text recognition in his mobile app, again:

A proprietary Scanner SDK like the Docutain Document Scanner SDK can be easily integrated within minutes. The SDK is based on technology, which is used by millions of users daily and that is permanently maintained and delivers state-of-the-art quality.

In comparison to a product like Google ML Kit, the Docutain Scanner SDK is way more sophisticated when it comes to edge detection, image enhancement and format-specific processing.

Customers can expect continuous support and automated updates with new functionalities, which is included in the licensing price. Once the Scanner SDK is integrated, developers no longer need to worry about versions or system compatibility as the SDK takes care of further development and ensuring functionality on new devices and operating system versions.

With the usage of e.g. Google ML Kit, it will be difficult to get direct support from Google and there is no guarantee that the feature will be enhanced.

The SDK also comes in different packages, tailored to the developer’s needs. This means that the SDK is not limited to one functionality only, but delivers several editing options such as cropping and filters besides scanning itself. Moreover, the Scanning SDK can be enhanced by a Data Capture SDK enabling OCR text recognition and Data Extracttion of recognized data. This also sets the Docutain Scanner SDK clearly apart from Google ML Kit, as the latter may not offer the same level of feature customization and fine-tuning.

Some features, especially cloud-based ones, rely on Google’s ecosystem, which may be a concern for privacy or compliance in certain industries when using Google ML Kit. In contrast to that, the Docutain SDK runs 100% offline, locally on the device.

Conclusion

When deciding to use open-source software or proprietary software it depends on the use case. For commercial purposes we recommend using proprietary software like the Docutain SDK to ensure continuous and quick support, state-of-the art functionality that comes with regular updates and many features. On the long run, it is more cost-efficient and save to work with a proprietary SDK.

Check out our proprietary Scanner SDK
Learn more about the Docutain SDK, providing document scanning, data capturing, OCR, data extraction and barcode scanning functionalities. It is available for Android, iOS and Windows. In addition to native integration, the SDK can be used for the most common cross-platform frameworks.
If you want to test the Document Scanner SDK without writing any lines of code, check out our Showcase Apps for Android & iOS or have a look at our GitHub examples.